The winner is: Pieces. The Drops don't have the crunchy shell and that is my favorite part. Also, the drops only come in milk chocolate. I heart dark chocolate. I will stick with the Pieces until they come out with Drops in the Hershey Special Dark. The Drops were good and for those of you who like Hershey Kisses, you'll love this gem of a candy that doesn't require unwrapping tiny pieces of foil.